The podcast evaluates struggling hitters as the MLB season reaches the two-month mark, offering insights for fantasy baseball enthusiasts. It begins with Gunnar Henderson, whose performance has dipped significantly compared to last year. Despite some struggles, there's optimism about his potential to bounce back, with an emphasis on underlying metrics suggesting improvement. Next, the discussion shifts to José Altuve and Marcus Semien, both aging players facing declines in performance, sparking debate over their viability in fantasy leagues.

Michael Harris' sporadic performance is also analyzed, alongside Brendan Doyle, who is navigating personal challenges as well as on-field underperformance. The analysis does not stop there; players like Christian Walker and Yainer Díaz are scrutinized, pointing out issues like injuries and swing mechanics that could affect their future contributions. The episode highlights the volatility and unpredictability of player performance in the game, urging listeners to consider both current form and underlying stats when making roster decisions.

The debate rages on as fantasy enthusiasts ponder whether William Contreras or Adley Rutschman will emerge as the top catcher for the 2025 MLB season. The Locked on Fantasy Baseball podcast dives deep into player rankings, providing insights into the catcher position trends.

Contreras, currently with the Milwaukee Brewers, has established himself as a formidable option, showcasing impressive stats since his transition from Atlanta. Rutschman, on the other hand, offers significant upside but has faced challenges that may affect his draft price.

Further discussions reveal varying opinions on key players like Salvador Perez, Yainer Diaz, and Cal Raleigh, with hosts emphasizing a late-round strategy for catcher selection to maximize value across other positions. The episode also highlights emerging talents like Austin Wells and intriguing options like Ivan Herrera, who could surprise in the upcoming season.